next up previous
Next: Replacing Modal Operators by Up: FIRST ORDER THEORIES OF Previous: Functions from Things to

Relations between Knowing What and Knowing That

As mentioned before, ``Pat knows Mike's telephone number'' is written


We can write ``Pat knows Mike's telephone number is 333-3333''


where K(P,Q) is the proposition that denot(P) knows the proposition Q and Concept1(``333-3333'') is some standard concept of that telephone number.

The two ways of expressing knowledge are somewhat interdefinable, since we can write




Here tex2html_wrap_inline1197 asserts that A is a constant, i.e. a concept such that we are willing to say that P knows X if he knows it equals A. This is clear enough for some domains like integers, but it is not obvious how to treat knowing a person.

Using the standard concept function Concept1, we might replace (41) by


with similar meaning.gif

(41) and (42) express a denotational definition of Know in terms of K. A conceptual definition seems to require something like


where Concept2 is a suitable function from things to concepts and may not be available for all sorts of objects.gif

John McCarthy
Tue May 14 16:07:43 PDT 1996